Public Value & Accountability

    If public land is committed to a decades-long industrial utility project, British Columbians — including ranchers and tenure holders — deserve transparency, enforceable protections, fair local treatment, and hard financial security.

    Why this matters

    This is not only a question of where the project goes. It is also a question of who benefits, who bears the burden, and what protections exist if things go wrong. If Crown land is used for a privately owned utility asset, the public deserves to know what it receives in return.

    If public land is used, what does the public get?

    Key questions that should be answered before any approval moves forward.

    Crown land is public land

    The proposed project sits on Crown land — land held in trust for all British Columbians. It is not private industrial land awaiting development.

    Private ownership is not public ownership

    Project materials describe a private partnership ownership structure. The asset would be privately held, even though it occupies public land.

    Ratepayers may still fund the power

    The electricity would be sold into the BC Hydro system. British Columbians could end up paying for power from an asset they do not own, built on land they do.

    Public benefit should be demonstrated, not assumed

    The burden of proof should be on the proponent to show clear, measurable public benefit — not on the public to prove harm.

    Minimum conditions for public accountability

    These are the principles that should guide any decision about industrial use of Crown land — not just for this project, but as a baseline for public accountability.

    Full public disclosure of tenure and land-use terms

    Clear demonstration of net public benefit

    Strong local compensation and community benefit commitments

    Direct compensation and protection for residents facing concentrated project burdens

    No loss of access, grazing, or watershed protection without enforceable offsets

    Full reclamation bond posted up front before construction

    Clear assignment of long-term liability and cleanup responsibility

    No approval without upfront reclamation security

    No large industrial project on Crown land should proceed without real financial security posted in advance to cover decommissioning, cleanup, disposal, road removal, and site restoration.

    "If public land is industrialized for decades, the public deserves more than promises."

    Stand up for public accountability

    Read our full campaign demands or get involved directly.